Tuesday, September 01, 2015

Fixing a Kenmore Vacuum That Won't Turn Off

One day, after using my old Kenmore Canister Vacuum cleaner, its motor would not turn off, even though I flipped the switch to the off position. The only way to turn off the vacuum in this state is to pull the plug, which causes sparking at the outlet because the motor is a big inductor.

This vacuum has the on-off switch built into the hose handle so that it is easy to turn on and off. This vacuum is actually made by Panasonic, and has been super reliable for the 10+ years that it has been in my family. This repair guide should apply to many vacuums made by Panasonic, and other manufacturers.

After some debugging, I found that the problem is a high amperage relay inside the vacuum canister that welds itself together from repeated on-off cycles. This actually happened twice to our vacuum. The first time this happened in 2007, I replaced the relay with an Omron 25A contact / 120VAC coil relay that I found on Mouser; it fit perfectly, and is the relay pictured below. Unfortunately, Omron discontinued that model of relay, but I bet something like this relay on Amazon would work just fine if you use the normally-open terminals.

Eight years later in 2015, the relay got stuck again; this time I decided to service the relay instead of replace it. After opening up the relay, I confirmed that the contacts welded themselves together from repeatedly turning the vacuum on and off, which causes arcing and enough heat to eventually melt the contacts together.

To repair the relay, I used a screwdriver to pry the contacts apart, and then used sand paper to sand off the carbon build up on the contacts and to remove the melted bits of the contact. After the contacts were clean and shiny, I put the relay back together and tested it out. We've been using the vacuum for a few months since then, and the repair has been holding up. It might not hold up as long as a brand new relay, but it should hold up for a while, and I can just repair the relay again if it melts again.

Here are the steps for the repair:

FIRST UNPLUG THE VACUUM!

Then, remove the hose from the canister:
Pull up on the HEPA filter cover to remove it and expose the case screws:
Remove the HEPA filter:
Remove the screws under the HEPA cover:
Open the bag compartment:
Remove the screws holding the blue case half to the grey case half:
Here's what you'll find inside the vacuum, the motor, the wire reel, and the relay (in my case, beside the motor):
Take a look at how the motor is oriented. You'll need to orient it the same way for the motor to fit into its spot:
Lift out the motor and move it aside, leaving the wires connected. You can now see the relay (the small box will all the wires connected to it):
Unscrew the relay:
Pop open both sides of the relay with something thin and small, like a small flat screw driver:
Slide the cover off:
Here's the contacts inside the relay. Noticed that the contacts are welded together. This is why the vacuum didn't turn off!
Here's the relay after separating the contacts:
Next, I sanded the contacts to remove the melted metal, and shine up the contact area:
At this point, I reassembled the vacuum which is the reverse of disassembly. The vacuum has been working great ever since!

18 comments:

Unknown said...

Fantastic illustration & photos. My 2 year old Panasonic won't turn on. Would like to know if this is a relay issue.

Unknown said...

My 2 year old Panasonic won't turn on. Do you think this is a relay issue?

Alex said...

It could be the relay. Sometimes they fail the opposite way; the contacts get dirty and no longer conduct electricity. It could also be the switch, the 360deg coupling, or the internal fuse (mine was covered with black shrink wrap, but it was a regular cylindrical glass fuse.

Alexander Riccio said...

Nice debugging :)

papajoe said...

Nice post!! Well done and very informative. I did not think to check the relay, which was the issue as the points were stuck and the motor would not turn off.

Unknown said...

Great blog, exactly what I needed, couldn't have explained it better. Good job.

Gary S.in SC

John M said...

You know that the fix for my Kenmore canister vacuum from 2004 made by Whirlpool, not Panasonic worked also. Once I got inside the motor compartment there were the same parts and the faulty relay. I cleaned it up as you demonstrated and the vacuum works fine. 3 years ago the switch went in the handle and I thought it was the same part gone bad. Replaced that switch, but it still would not cut off. Of course neither Sears or Whirlpool carries that relay anymore. So cleaned up the relay and my word, it works fine!
Thanks again you just saved me some time and money.
John

Unknown said...

Thank you very much for posting this solution. This was exactly what was wrong with my Kenmore canister and now it works perfectly! Thanks!

jojocamel said...

One thing you CAN do to prevent this from occurring in the future is to add a "RC Quench Circuit" to bypass the initial current rush. I've used simple ceramic bypass caps across the power switch successfully in old integrated tube amplifiers where the switch is incorporated into the volume or tone controls. Such vintage switches are not readily available and an addition of suppression can prolong the life of the switch. Hope this helps.

Unknown said...

I have a Kenmore canister that won't shut off. I found your blog on dealing
with the problem and was able to open the machine, find the relay, identify
it and order a new one. I was unable to open the relay that is in the machine
to deal with possible fused contacts but I was pleased at the prospect of
being able to use the machine if the new relay works. Before I found your
Blog I made the mistake of assuming that the problem was a boked slide switch.
I bought a new one but I need advice on connecting the switch to the wires
on the handle. I was wondering if you could describe how the handle slide
switch is connected to the handle wires. My email address is 530wayne@comcsst.net
Thank you,
Wayne

Jo Brack said...

Thanks Alex! Worked like a charm. My vacuum assembly is a bit different but once I figured that out and cleaned the relay it is back in business. The time you took to post this fix is really appreciated. All the best!

Unknown said...

I have the same problem, thing is I dont want to fix it but I love my vacuum

Unknown said...

Thank you so much Alex, your step by step pictured instructions fixed my Kenmore vacuum cleaner. I had the same symptom as you, would not turn off. With a little help from another website suggesting that I pry-off the cord return bar I found the remaining two screws. After sanding the relay contacts, I reassembled the unit, and it worked like a charm. This vacuum is almost 20 years old, I can't wait to see how much longer it lasts.

Unknown said...

Our vacuum quit and it was EXACTLY what you said! Fixed in a jiffy with your kind posts. Thanks so much for this information.

Unknown said...

Our vacuum quit and it was EXACTLY what you said! Fixed in a jiffy with your kind posts. Thanks so much for this information.

Unknown said...

Thank you for posting this! I have the exact same issue with my Panasonic branded vacuum. I will do this surgery on it today. From what I understand, it should have a capacitor or something similar to prevent/reduce arcing. I will look that up and see if I can do a mod to prevent this from happening again and again.

Unknown said...

Great job with pics and instructions. My Kenmore wouldn't shut off after 19 years. I bought the switch for $32 thinking that was it. I installed it, would NOT shut off. I did more research and found your blog. I took the relay apart, both contacts were corroded but not welded. I sanded them smooth with an emory board, blew it off, re-installed, and voila! Thank you so much.

Joseph said...

Thank you for the detailed information, I have the same problem with the rilay, I'm down to the motor but I can't lift it up is there a screw or something?